• Brent oil prices are down 15% across the board since last week.
  • This has already been reflected on ethanol prices in Brazil.
  • What happens to the sugar and ethanol parity if oil prices keep trading lower?

 The Omicron Effect 

  • The discovery of another COVID variant, Omicron, has caused havoc in markets across the world since last week.
  • Brent oil prices fell around 15% across the board in one week, going from over $80/barrel to under $70/barrel – at the time of writing.
  • Once vaccination was leading a recovery in prices, as fuel demand was expected to pick up.
  • Now, fear of more lockdowns imposed across the world lead to a bearish view for oil.

undefined
  • Today, OPEC+ has a meeting to decide on whether it will stick with the initial plan of raising oil production by 400kbpd.
  • But this path was drawn before this variable (Omicron) was added to the mix.
  • In case it does decide to stay on course, the market reaction could be negative.

What Happens to the Ethanol Parity in Brazil? 

  • Just for you to see how dynamic things are, just 10 days ago we were writing about how ethanol had surpassed sugar at the spot parities and what to expect. 
  • The negative outlook for oil is already weighting on ethanol prices in Brazil, with the daily BM&F hydrous falling BRL100/cbm in 1 week.
  • And the spot parity between sugar and ethanol now sees the sweetener paying over 100pts more than ethanol.
  • But what happens to the ethanol parity if Brent oil prices continues to fall?

undefined

  • Assuming a 70% parity for ethanol and gasoline (which is the limit for ethanol competitiveness), when we run the scenarios for different Brent oil prices, we get a level of hydrous and transform to a No.11 basis so we can compare to sugar No.11.
  • Currently, ethanol prices are at around 17c/lb if Brent oil falls down to $50/barrel this means that hydrous ethanol could go down to under 15c/lb.
  • And why is this important?
undefined

  • This means that sugar support can fall since, even at a lower price point, Brazilian millers can capture higher returns with sugar than with ethanol.
  • The lower Brent oil goes, the lower goes sugar downside…

A Brief Note on Ethanol and Gasoline Parity

  • In our model scenarios we run a 70% ethanol and gasoline parity since this is the benchmark for ethanol competitiveness.
  • It works like a base scenario.
  • However, ethanol and gasoline parity for this past 2021/22 season has averaged 74% – looking to SP state.
  • Therefore, if you consider a higher parity then the support for ethanol becomes a bit higher.

undefined

Other Insights that may be of interest 

Interactive Data Reports that may be of interest…

Ana Zancaner

Ana graduated from Insper University Sao Paulo in 2013, with a bachelor’s degree in business administration. She joined CZ as an intern in 2013 and is now our senior analyst in our Sao Paulo office. At CZ she is responsible mainly for analysis of the Brazilian sugar and ethanol sector but supporting other consulting requests as well.

More from this author